Microstructures
by George Langford, Sc.D., Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA, 1966
Copyright©
2005 by George Langford
Low Alloy Steels - Lesson 3 - Second specimen
Chair spring that fatigued at 200X etched
Here we have a chair spring that failed in fatigue.  The photomicrograph at left was made at 200X with a Nital etch.

Note the decarburization and seams, which are artifacts of careless hot rolling practice prior to the wire drawing.  Folded over flash (fins) from the rolling operation was not removed and acted to concentrate stress in the finished spring.
Explanation about torsion in a spring
The wire in a coil spring like this one is under torsional stress (not bending) during compression or extension of the spring.  The maximum tensile stress occurs at 45 degrees to the longitudinal axis of the wire at the unblemished surface of the wire.  However, the greatest stress is actually at the bottom of the crevices formed by the defects, so the longitudinal seams act as stress risers regardless of whether the spring is compressed or extended.

The next four photomicrographs illustrate the effects of differential hardenability brought about by macrosegregation.

Start with Specimen 3.